Counsellor, Therapist, Psychotherapist, Psychologist or Psychiatrist? How do I find the right mental health support, and what’s the difference between these professions?*
More of us than ever are seeking mental health support nowadays, and not a moment too soon given that one out of three of British adults say their mental health has deteriorated since the start of the pandemic (rising to nine out of ten young people). Thankfully, the stigma around accessing counselling and therapy has declined drastically in recent years, but the confusion hasn’t. There are many types of mental health professionals in the UK, making it very difficult for the lay person seeking help to know who they should contact. If you’re looking to seek mental health support but are struggling to tell the difference between a counsellor, psychotherapist (or more casually, a ‘therapist’), psychologist and psychiatrist you’re in the right place.
In short, the aforementioned professions describe mental health practitioners who are trained to work with mental distress but have different training backgrounds, ways of working, and are likely to focus on different areas. For example, you might find a counsellor who works specifically with trauma or eating disorders, a psychotherapist who focuses on identifying how experiences from your past affect your present, a clinical psychologist who you may see for an ADHD diagnosis, or a psychiatrist who may help you deal with a mood disorder like bipolar.
To complicate matters further, “therapists,” a term that is often used to refer to counsellors, psychotherapists and counselling psychologists, are trained in different modalities or ways of working. Simply put, this is the theory they subscribe to – the way that they have learnt to understand your stressors, concerns and behaviours. Most of the time, this is nothing to worry about; a mental health practitioner should respond to you on a personal level, regardless of the modality in which they are trained. But when you are looking for a practitioner, it may be worth knowing a little about these approaches and finding one that suits. BACP have pulled together a handy guide.
The table below should help clear up the main differences between the professional titles:
Title: |
What they do: |
Education: |
Main accrediting bodies:
|
How to seek this
kind of help: |
Price: |
Counsellors and Psychotherapists: These titles are not protected in the UK, which means someone can
use them without any training at all. Be sure that you seek out someone who
is accredited or registered with a recognised body. |
|||||
Counsellor |
Counsellors generally
offer “talking therapy” and work with clients to cover a wide range of mental
health concerns, such as depression, anxiety, stress, loss, relationship
problems, eating disorders, addiction, trauma, change and much more. You can expect a
counsellor to provide a safe space for you to talk about your concerns and
support you in finding solutions (which might include finding acceptance or
new ways of looking at a problem). Traditionally
counsellors have been associated with shorter term work (between 6-12
sessions) but may work longer-term depending on their training background and
client needs. |
Counsellors are
typically educated to degree level and have then undertaken an additional
qualification such as a certificate, diploma, or master’s degree in
counselling. Once a counsellor has
reached a minimum standard of education and experience, they can apply for
accreditation from a professional organisation that will ensure they abide by
ethical standards, get appropriate further education and support, and are
subject to a complaint’s procedure (see tab to right). |
BACP UKCP NCP HPCP Counsellors and
psychotherapists should display their accreditation and/or qualifications on
their professional profiles. If they don’t, it is
okay to send a message asking about these – it’s important to know. |
The easiest way to
work with a counsellor or psychotherapist is in “private practice” – where
you pay for your own treatment. Counselling and psychotherapy can take place
face-to-face, or via the phone / a video conferencing platform. Word of mouth is often
the best way to find a counsellor or psychotherapist, so ask around. If you
can’t do that there are several directories you can search such as Welldoing.org. There are
also directories for specific needs – for instance, the Black, African
and Asian Therapy Network (BAATN) is
great for finding a BIPOC counsellor or Pink
Therapy for LGBTQI+ clients or the Neurodivergent
therapist network. If you are based
in London, Berlin, or Paris, you can check Stillpoint’s
local directories. While counsellors and
psychotherapists are sometimes available on the NHS, wait times are often
long, and are generally limited to Cognitive Behavioural approaches (which
won’t appeal to everyone). You can talk to your doctor or search online for
NHS-funded mental health support. |
Varies depending on
location and level of experience of your counsellor / psychotherapist. Typically, you can
expect to pay between £55-100 / session. Counsellors and
psychotherapists often offer a discount for students, the retired and the
unemployed. You might be able to access free counselling via your employer or
through a charitable organisation like MIND. If money is tight, it
may be worth reducing the frequency of your sessions – perhaps seeing your
counsellor / psychotherapist once every fortnight instead of weekly. |
Psychotherapist |
As above. Traditionally,
psychotherapists are associated with working over the longer term with their
clients, as their trainings are geared towards this practice. Longer term can
be from several months to several years – though like counselling, many will
engage in shorter term work. Like with counselling,
there are a myriad of approaches (from CBT to body centred or dynamic
therapies) but for the most part, these consist of regular (generally weekly)
confidential discussions. |
Qualified
psychotherapists are typically educated to post-graduate degree level over a
period of at least four years. Most are required to have undergone
psychotherapy themselves. As above, always look
for a psychotherapist who is accredited with a recognised governing body.
|
|||
Please note that the terms “counsellor”, “psychotherapist”,
and “therapist” are often used interchangeably. A practitioner will typically
choose the professional title in which they were trained and feel most
comfortable. The most important thing is that your professional is a good
“match” so it might be worth speaking to a few before settling into your
choice. |
|||||
Psychologists: You might hear the term “psychologist” being used a lot. There
are many types of psychologists, who work in many sectors such as business,
education and research. When referring to a mental health professional, most
people are referring to either a Counselling or a Clinical Psychologist. |
|||||
Counselling
Psychologist |
Like counsellors and
psychotherapists, counselling psychologists offer talking therapy, though you
typically find them working within an organisation. Counselling
Psychologists may also be asked to make diagnoses about someone’s mental
health condition. They may work with more serious, long term mental health
conditions such as bipolar disorder and schizophrenia. They cannot prescribe
medication. |
Must have a doctorate
level qualification in Counselling Psychology (however, Counselling
Psychologists are not medical doctors). |
BPS HPCP |
Often, Counselling
Psychologists work for the NHS or within the education sector (providing
counselling to young people), therefore you are typically referred to them by
your doctor or someone working in pastoral care. Some Counselling
Psychologists do work in private practice, and you can find them in the usual
directories; for instance, Welldoing.org.
|
If accessed via the
NHS, it will be free to see a Counselling Psychologist, but please note that
typically only individuals with severe mental health problems will be
referred. In private practice,
you can expect to pay around £75-£120 / hour. |
Clinical Psychologist |
Typically, Clinical
Psychologists are focussed on diagnosis, and thinking up treatment plans to
improve clients’ quality of life. They cannot prescribe
medication. |
Must have a doctorate
level qualification in Clinical Psychology (however, Clinical Psychologists
are not medical doctors). |
BPS ACP-UK HCPC |
Clinical Psychologists
typically work within the NHS or in prisons, therefore you must normally be
referred to them. |
N/A |
Psychiatrists: Specialist medical doctors, who can prescribe medication |
|||||
Psychiatrist |
Medical doctors
focused on preventing, diagnosing and treating mental illnesses. Similar to
Clinical Psychologists, Psychiatrists are more involved in diagnosis and
prevention of mental health disorders than the therapeutic treatments (such
as talking therapy). However, psychiatrists can prescribe medication. It is not uncommon to
have both a psychiatrist and a talking therapist who will liaise every now
and then about your treatment with your consent. |
Psychiatrists are
medical doctors (trained for 5 years + 2 years general training in a
hospital), with (at least) an additional 3-year training in psychiatry. Though some
psychiatrists are also trained in psychotherapy, most are not and will focus
mostly on assessment and pharmacological treatment and support |
General Medical
Council Royal College of
Psychiatrists |
Psychiatrists
typically work for the NHS or in private hospitals and prisons. You must
usually be referred to them. |
Private consultations
can be very expensive and vary across the country. However, treatment is
usually coordinated via your NHS GP or private healthcare who generally cover
the costs of prescriptions if necessary. Outside of acute situations, visits
with psychiatrists tend to be less frequent than those with talking
therapists. |
Emergency Help: |
|||||
Emergency help |
There are many
hotlines for mental health emergencies, the most famous being The
Samaritans. You can call them, for free, on 116 123, at any time of day or
night. This site
has some alternative hotlines that may be of interest. Such hotlines are
intended for crisis situations, after which you can access longer term mental
health support in one of the ways described above (with the support of your
doctor - if you choose to). Remember, if you
are feeling so low that you’re worried you may be a danger to yourself or
to someone else you should call 999 or check yourself into your local
A&E department. Please do not be
afraid to seek help, in whichever form is most useful to you. |
*Please note, this article aims to differentiate between the different mental health professionals in the UK: there may be differences in other countries.
Alex Grunnill works for Stillpoint, and is based in London, UK. She is passionate about psychology, travelling, sustainability and linguistics. She hopes eventually to train as a psychotherapist. You can find her on Linked In.
Stillpoint is an organisation that aims to make psychology more publicly accessible, through events, online content and a virtual community for the psychologically curious.